Opens in a new tab
Join us in championing courageous and independent journalism!
Support Daraj

From Lourdes to the World: We Know What Happened; So What Has Changed?

Zeina Allouch
International Child Protection Expert
Lebanon
Published on 06.10.2026
Reading time: 9 minutes

Between the two rulings, the stages, concerts, and celebrations continued. In Beirut, a campaign emerged under the slogan “Lebanon Does Not Welcome Saad Lamjarred,” while others continued to share songs and public spaces with him. Did it not occur to an artist who shares a song and a stage with him, then greets and embraces him, that this is not merely an artistic moment or a personal choice? What does that image mean to someone who has been raped? And what does it tell us about the distance that sometimes separates what we know about violence from the position we take toward it?

Loading the Elevenlabs Text to Speech AudioNative Player...

In Spotlight, the film based on the investigative reporting published by The Boston Globe in 2002, the story does not begin with an attempt to expose a single abuser. It starts with a thread that leads the journalists to a network far larger than they had expected. What initially appeared to be isolated cases of clergy sexually abusing children soon revealed a pattern that had persisted for years within the Archdiocese of Boston. As the investigation widened, allegations implicated nearly 250 priests in the Boston area, while hundreds of survivors came forward publicly. The story was no longer simply: Who was the priest who committed the abuse? It became: How could so many acts of abuse have happened, continued, and remained protected for so long?

In the film, attorney Mitchell Garabedian says something difficult to forget: “If it takes a village to raise a child, it takes a village to abuse one.” Perhaps the power of this sentence lies in the way it shifts the question from where we are accustomed to placing it. It does not absolve the perpetrator of responsibility, but it forces us to widen our field of vision: What surrounds him? Who knows? Who suspects? Who remains silent? Who protects? Who justifies? And who fears for the reputation of the institution more than they fear for the person who has been harmed?

This is what mattered in Spotlight. The journalists were no longer pursuing individual names so much as the structure that had allowed abuse to happen, continue, and remain hidden.

I thought about this “village” as I followed Pope Leo XIV’s meeting in Lourdes with people who survived sexual abuse within the Church. The meeting was scheduled to last an hour and extended to nearly two. The Pope listened to survivors, some individually and then as a group. They spoke to him not only about what they had endured, but about institutional responsibility and the need to confront the systemic nature of abuse.

I do not know what it means for someone to sit before the highest authority of the institution associated with their pain and tell their story. Nor do I want to assume that such a meeting constitutes healing, or that listening is equivalent to justice. We have no right to ask a symbolic encounter to carry more than it can bear. An apology cannot restore a stolen childhood. Empathy does not hold accountable those who remained silent. Listening does not open archives, nor can it, on its own, repair institutions that protected themselves.

But there is something in the image that deserves our attention: the institution, if only for a moment, sits before those harmed by its system and listens to their account of what happened.

And perhaps here, in Lebanon, we need to ask: How did we protect Mansour Labaki?

The “village” surrounding Lebanese priest Mansour Labaki has its own story to tell. For years, a religious and social system chose to protect him throughout a long ecclesiastical and judicial process that culminated in his criminal conviction in France in 2021 for the rape and sexual assault of minors. He was sentenced to fifteen years in prison and was subsequently dismissed from the clerical state by a Vatican decision.

But I do not want to write about Mansour Labaki as much as I want to write about what surrounded him: those who supported him, stood by him, embraced him, and opposed his extradition to the French authorities. About the aura surrounding a religious figure and the authority society grants someone perceived as a representative of the sacred. About institutions that struggle to imagine themselves as places capable of producing harm. And about people who may find it less painful to doubt a girl or a woman than to question a man they loved and trusted.

What does it mean for a survivor to summon the strength to name what happened, only to discover that she must confront not only the person who harmed her but an entire collective memory of him? She says: This man harmed me. And society answers: But you do not understand what he means to us.

Perhaps this is where the second violation begins.

It is not necessarily physical. It is social, symbolic, and institutional. It happens when the survivor is required, again and again, to prove her harm, while the institution is not required to explain its silence. Her memory, the timing of her disclosure, her behaviour, and her motives are scrutinized, while the image of the man she speaks about remains surrounded by admiration and nostalgia.

A Stage for Saad Lamjarred

Then I think of Saad Lamjarred. The two cases are different and should not be conflated legally or institutionally. But they meet around another question: What do societies do once sexual violence becomes part of the public record?

In France, Lamjarred was convicted of rape in 2023 and sentenced to six years in prison before appealing the verdict. In September 2026, the Court of Appeal convicted him again and sentenced him to ten years in prison.

Yet between the two rulings, the stages, concerts, and celebrations continued. In Beirut, a campaign emerged under the slogan “Lebanon Does Not Welcome Saad Lamjarred,” while others continued to share songs and public spaces with him. Did it not occur to an artist who shares a song and a stage with him, then greets and embraces him, that this is not merely an artistic moment or a personal choice? What does that image mean to someone who has been raped? And what does it tell us about the distance that sometimes separates what we know about violence from the position we take toward it?

These Are Not Simply Personal Choices

Perhaps here, too, we need to ask about that fine line between the personal and the public. People have a right to their relationships, choices, and private feelings. But what happens when a choice moves onto the stage, into an image, a concert, or a public space? When does an act cease to be merely personal and become a message, even when the person involved never intended to send one?

This is not about policing people’s choices or demanding some kind of “pure” private life. It is about recognizing that power, visibility, and access to a platform carry responsibility, and that some actions, once made public, acquire meanings that exceed the personal intentions of those who perform them.

It may seem like an old debate about whether we can separate the artist from what the artist has done. But another question is often missing: What do survivors hear when the applause begins?

And for me, this does not stop at rape and sexual abuse. What about the other forms of violence we have learned to live with because they have become ordinary? What about our everyday choices when a human being is turned into a body, an image, a source of pleasure, or an object of consumption? What about discourse, advertising, art, and entertainment when they reproduce relations of power that objectify those who are most vulnerable, or turn their humiliation into something that can be watched, laughed at, and marketed? And what about violence we do not commit with our own hands, but to which we give space, buy a ticket, repost, or applaud?

Perhaps the question is not only: Did this person commit a crime? It is also: What do we choose to normalize? What do we accept becoming spectacle? And where do we stand when one person’s freedom, fame, or power becomes possible at the expense of the dignity of someone with less ability to speak, refuse, or reach the same platform?

A stage is not a courtroom. An audience is not a jury. A ticket is not a judicial verdict. But a platform is not entirely innocent either. It confers visibility. It reproduces status. It says, in one way or another, who is still considered worthy of occupying public space, whose image can still be raised, and who can still be celebrated.

The question, then, goes beyond Saad Lamjarred himself: What are we reproducing when we applaud? And what boundaries do we draw, as a society, between what we recognize as violence and what we continue to grant social legitimacy?

That is why I do not ask only what applauding Saad Lamjarred means. I ask what it means to a young woman who was raped and has not yet spoken; to a child trying to understand whether what happened to them is something worth telling someone about; to a woman who spoke and was not believed; and to everyone who has experienced some form of violence only to watch the person, or the structure, that harmed them resume its place in society as though nothing had happened.

What is most frightening about Spotlight, a film whose screening in Lebanon was prevented amid the prevailing public climate, is not the discovery that men committed crimes against children. It is the discovery of how many ordinary people, performing their ordinary roles, are required for abuse to continue: a religious leader protecting the institution; a lawyer settling a case; an official transferring a priest from one place to another; a family afraid of scandal; someone who knows part of the story and prefers not to know the rest.

Even the newspaper itself was not outside this circle. It had to confront the fact that, in earlier years, it had received signals and information that did not become the investigation they should have become.

And this is where the question becomes more difficult:

Because we, too, are the village.

This is why I do not want us to turn the Lourdes meeting into a success story about an institution that has finally learned to listen to survivors. The question is not only whether the institution listened, but what it will do with what it heard. Will procedures change? Will files be opened? Will reporting mechanisms become genuinely independent? Will those who knew and failed to act be questioned? Will survivors receive the forms of support they themselves choose, rather than those the institution decides are appropriate for them? And will another person be able to speak ten years from now without paying the same price?

Most importantly: Will we leave survivors the right to remain silent?

They do not owe us their testimonies. They do not owe us the details of their harm so that we may learn from them. They do not owe us a neatly organized story that can be placed in a report, a film, or an awareness campaign. Nor do they owe an institution forgiveness because it apologized, or reconciliation because it finally decided to listen.

Perhaps we need to stop asking survivors, for a moment:

What happened to you?

And ask ourselves instead:

What did we do with what we knew?

And has the village changed?