The participating outlets are Sahih Masr, Mada Masr, and Al Manassa (Egypt); Megaphone, Daraj, and Sifr (Lebanon); Nawaat (Tunisia); and Al Jumhuriya (Syria).
During the social protection sessions at the “Egyptians Forum,” Minister of Social Solidarity Maya Morsy presented the results of the Takaful and Karama program, claiming that since its launch 11 years ago, approximately 2.2 million families had graduated from the program after moving from poverty to economic productivity.
But how accurately does this claim reflect reality?
Behind the official figures, impoverished families face decisions to suspend their benefits or remove them from beneficiary lists, while the announced allocations fall short of keeping pace with inflation and the rising cost of living.
While the government speaks of ensuring that subsidies reach those entitled to them, the social safety net on which millions of Egyptians depend is shrinking. Budget figures alone fail to show how much support actually reaches the most vulnerable groups or whether it is sufficient to protect them from poverty.
Among those who were surprised to find themselves removed from the program is Mahga El Mabrouk, a divorced mother of three who received benefits for just over a year. Her monthly payment initially stood at EGP 445 and gradually increased to around EGP 795. Although the amount was not enough to allow her to stop working as a domestic cleaner, she considered it a reliable source of income.
“I applied for the benefits four years ago, on the advice of a woman whose house I clean, after I complained that my children’s father wasn’t contributing to their expenses,” Mahga says. “But I only started receiving payments a year and nine months after submitting my application. During that time, I regularly visited the social solidarity office responsible for my area, where the employee kept telling me that no decision had been made on my application.”
Mahga eventually began receiving Takaful and Karama benefits, but the payments were irregular, arriving every two or three months rather than monthly. Then, at the end of last year, she was surprised to discover that her payment card had stopped working.
When she visited the social solidarity office, she was informed that she had been removed from the list of beneficiaries because she was receiving another form of support: an exemption from tuition fees for her children at Al-Azhar educational institutes. Such exemptions have been available for years, with low-income families able to apply to Al-Azhar for a waiver that is generally granted without difficulty. Another reason cited was that she had acted as a guarantor for her brother’s consumer loan to purchase a three-wheeled motorized vehicle.
“I didn’t lie when I applied for the benefits. I told the employee that my children attended Al-Azhar schools and were exempt from tuition fees, and he told me there was no problem with that,” Mahga says. “Children of divorced mothers are exempt from tuition fees at public and experimental schools, and their mothers can still receive Takaful and Karama benefits.”
At the end of last month, reports circulated claiming that three million beneficiaries had been removed from the program, a claim the Cabinet denied. The Ministry of Social Solidarity also stated that no family or individual is removed from the program unless specific eligibility conditions are met. These include changes in marital status, a family member obtaining employment with social insurance coverage, travel, the death of a beneficiary, or the acquisition of agricultural land or a business.
Hamdy Fathy, a pseudonym for an employee at the Ministry of Social Solidarity, says beneficiaries are routinely removed from the program in accordance with ministry instructions when they no longer meet eligibility requirements. Although they have the right to appeal, he confirms that, throughout his time at the ministry, he has never seen a beneficiary reinstated after being removed.
In the 2026/2027 budget, allocations for the Takaful and Karama program reached EGP 55.2 billion, an increase of just 2%, while inflation stood at approximately 11.3%. The number of beneficiaries fell to 4.7 million, a decline of around half a million people who were removed from the program for various reasons.
Cut Off from Subsidies
Three years ago, Hageer Rady applied to Egypt’s telecommunications provider for a landline so she could access the internet. However, because she lives in an informal settlement on the rural-urban outskirts of Qanater El Khayreya in Qalyubia Governorate, she was told that no landlines were available in her area.
She turned instead to a mobile network operator for a more expensive wireless internet service, allowing her eldest daughter to access the internet for her studies. What she did not know was that this service would cost her the in-kind subsidies she relied on.
The Ministry of Supply and Internal Trade removed her from the subsidy system as part of a decision affecting 850,000 citizens whose ration cards were deactivated, ostensibly to ensure that subsidies reached those who needed them most. Several reasons were cited for these removals, including reports of electricity theft, enrollment in private schools charging more than EGP 20,000 in tuition fees, high mobile phone bills, and ownership of a new car.
“When I went to collect subsidized bread, I was surprised to find that my ration card had been deactivated,” Hageer says. “The bakery owner told me that thousands of cards had been suspended and that I needed to find out why and file an appeal. I did exactly that, but I still haven’t received a response.”
For Hageer, internet access is not a luxury. Her work in marketing depends on it, as does the education of her three children. Many teachers now offer private tutoring online to save time and transportation costs, an arrangement that also suits her because it means she does not have to take her children from one tutoring session to another. Yet the state treats her reliance on this service as a luxury that justifies withdrawing her subsidies.
Hageer is one of millions of Egyptians affected by the shrinking social safety net that has existed for decades. Meanwhile, during the third day’s sessions of the Egyptians Forum, the government touted its social support packages, relying on misleading budget figures that fail to account for declining purchasing power or inflation, while presenting the reduction in the number of subsidy recipients as a measure to streamline the system and ensure that support reaches those who need it most.
Subsidies and Misleading Figures
According to the current budget, which came into effect on July 1, 2026, allocations for subsidies amount to EGP 836.8 billion, an increase of approximately 16% compared with last year’s budget. This is the figure the government consistently highlights in its statements about increased social support. However, it fails to account for inflation and conceals several misleading calculations.
The first misleading calculation involves combining social assistance with subsidies benefiting the wealthy and presenting them as a single figure. The total allocation includes EGP 48.043 billion in export subsidies, an increase of EGP 3 billion, approximately EGP 26 billion in support for industrial activities, and EGP 6 billion in loan interest subsidies. This means that around 9.5% of the funds supposedly allocated to supporting the poor goes directly into the pockets of the wealthy.
Meanwhile, subsidies for petroleum products have been sharply reduced in the budget, falling from EGP 75.03 billion to EGP 15.84 billion. Electricity subsidies, however, have risen from EGP 75 billion to EGP 104.16 billion, an increase of 38.6%.
This means that more than 22% of the total subsidy allocation is directed toward energy, from which factories benefit disproportionately. Moreover, the existence of these subsidies in previous years has not prevented repeated increases in electricity prices. The latest increase came in April, when electricity tariffs rose by between 16% and 28%. In March, prices for fuel, natural gas, and cooking gas cylinders increased by between 14% and 30%.
The budget’s subsidy allocation also includes EGP 169.2 billion earmarked to repay government debts to social insurance funds. These are pension funds that the state borrowed from workers and other contributors to the retirement insurance system.
As a result, nearly 50% of the budget allocated to subsidies either benefits the wealthy through export incentives, business support, and energy subsidies for factories, or is used to repay money the state owes to citizens, rather than providing them with direct support.
According to the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights (EIPR), subsidies as a share of total government expenditure have fallen from 21% in the 2016/2017 fiscal year to 10.1% in 2026/2027, effectively halving over the past decade. Meanwhile, the share allocated to debt principal repayments and interest payments has risen from 44.7% to 63.9%. In other words, the increase in debt servicing expenditure has exceeded the savings made through subsidy reductions.
In-Kind Subsidies
The latest budget allocates approximately EGP 178.3 billion to in-kind food subsidies, including EGP 142.3 billion for bread subsidies and EGP 36 billion for ration cards, an increase of around 11% compared with the 2025/2026 budget.
However, increased spending on food subsidies does not necessarily translate into improved access to food. A review of successive budgets reveals a steady rise in food subsidy allocations, from EGP 31 billion in the 2010/2011 fiscal year to EGP 134.1 billion in 2024/2025, and finally to EGP 178.3 billion in the latest budget. Yet this increase is a direct result of rising wheat import costs and the depreciation of the Egyptian pound against the US dollar.
Over the same period, bread subsidies surged from EGP 22.4 billion to EGP 142.3 billion. However, this increase in spending coincided with a reduction in the scope of coverage. The number of people benefiting from subsidized bread fell from 77 million in 2017/2018 to 72 million in 2024/2025. The total number of subsidized loaves allocated also declined from 140 billion to 96.5 billion, while the price of a loaf increased from 5 to 20 piasters and its weight was reduced from 130 grams to 90 grams.
Poverty in Egypt
Subsidies are intended to strengthen people’s ability to withstand poverty and, ultimately, reduce it. In Egypt, however, the situation tells a different story. Despite the government’s emphasis on its social protection programs, poverty continues to rise.
Although the Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics (CAPMAS) has withheld poverty figures since 2023, the latest officially recorded Egyptian poverty rate stood at 29.5% in 2021. The World Bank, meanwhile, estimated Egypt’s poverty rate at 33.5% for the same year.
One way to estimate poverty levels in Egypt is to refer to the national poverty thresholds published by CAPMAS in 2019. At the time, the agency classified individuals earning less than EGP 857 per month as poor, while those earning less than EGP 550 were considered to be living in extreme poverty.
Based on these thresholds, a family of four would be considered poor if its monthly income fell below EGP 3,428, and extremely poor if it earned less than EGP 2,200.
These figures were calculated when the US dollar was worth no more than EGP 15.7. At the time of writing, the exchange rate stands at approximately EGP 54 to the dollar, while its lowest rate this year was EGP 48.
Using an average exchange rate of around EGP 50 to the dollar, the poverty threshold would rise to approximately EGP 2,750 per person, while the extreme poverty threshold would reach around EGP 1,750.
Under this calculation, a family earning less than approximately EGP 11,000 per month would fall below the poverty line, while a family earning EGP 7,000 would be considered to be living in extreme poverty.
Meanwhile, the minimum monthly wage for public sector employees stands at EGP 8,000, compared with EGP 7,000 in the private sector, a minimum that many factories do not enforce.
The implications of poverty are particularly evident in the affordability of a healthy diet. According to a World Bank study published on June 29, 2026, food insecurity and poverty have increased among Egypt’s most vulnerable populations, according to a wide range of indicators.
Between 2017, when the Egyptian pound underwent its first flotation under President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, and the latest flotation in 2024, the number of Egyptians unable to afford a healthy diet rose by approximately 27%, from 52 million in 2017 to 66 million in 2024, an increase of 14 million people.
While the government highlights social spending figures and the exit of millions of families from the Takaful and Karama program at the Egyptians Forum, actual budget allocations, beneficiaries’ testimonies, and poverty indicators suggest that higher figures on paper do not necessarily translate into stronger social protection.
Support intended to shield families from poverty is increasingly subject to exclusion criteria that do not always reflect their actual needs. Meanwhile, its purchasing power continues to erode as the costs of food and energy rise, alongside the growing burden of debt servicing.






